Our head office has moved, just steps away!
For a long time, annual performance reviews were considered a sound management practice. Every year, managers met with their employees, reviewed the previous months, discussed objectives achieved, and set priorities for the year ahead. For many organizations, this was seen as one of the most important exercises of the year.

Today, our HR Consulting Services Team wonders whether this approach still truly meets the needs of organizations and employees.

To be clear, our HR Consulting Services Team is not suggesting that performance reviews should be abandoned. Quite the opposite. We believe employees need feedback, recognition, and opportunities to talk with their managers. What we question, rather, is the idea that a single annual meeting is the best time to discuss performance. Because the reality is that performance is not managed once a year. It is managed throughout the year.

Why annual performance reviews are no longer enough on their own

A conversation that sometimes comes far too late

Our HR Consulting Services Team is reminded of a situation we recently helped a client navigate. A manager was preparing his team’s annual reviews and had begun documenting performance issues he had observed over several months. He wanted to use the meeting to share his concerns with one of his employees.

As we discussed the situation, one question kept coming up: was the employee already aware of these concerns? Had they been brought to his attention throughout the year?

As our HR Consulting Services Team suspected, his answer was mixed. Certain expectations had been mentioned from time to time, and a few comments had been made during the year. However, no clear conversation had actually taken place. And that is precisely one of the problems with annual reviews when they become the primary tool for managing performance.

When an employee learns during an annual review that a problem has existed for several months, it is often too late to turn that meeting into a meaningful development opportunity. The exercise becomes more of an assessment than an opportunity for improvement. Nobody likes to be caught off guard during a performance review, and this kind of situation can put an employee on the defensive, causing them to withdraw rather than engage in a constructive discussion.

The world of work is changing faster than before

We also need to recognize that organizations are evolving much more quickly than they used to. Priorities change, teams evolve, projects follow one another, and expectations sometimes need to be adjusted along the way. In this context, a discussion held once a year can quickly become insufficient.

Imagine a sports coach waiting until the end of the season to discuss the team’s performance. The idea seems almost absurd. Adjustments need to be made while the game is being played, not several months later.

Managing performance often works the same way. The more frequent the conversations, the easier it is to make adjustments. Employees know where they stand, understand what is expected of them, and can get back on track quickly when needed.

Feedback should not be an event

Even today, in many organizations, performance reviews are still treated as an annual event. Forms are prepared, data is compiled, meetings are scheduled, and then everyone moves on until the following year. The risk is that performance management becomes concentrated into a single moment.

Yet the best managers our HR Consulting Services Team meets often approach things differently. They use annual reviews as an opportunity to take stock, but not as their main management tool. Conversations about performance, development, objectives, and expectations already take place regularly throughout the year.

As a result, the annual review rarely brings surprises. It becomes more of a summary than a revelation. And that is probably how it should be used.

Supporting recognition and development throughout the year

Recognition deserves more than once a year

This reflection is not only about difficulties or performance issues. It is also about recognition.

An employee who does excellent work in February should not have to wait 12 months to hear that they have made a positive contribution to the organization. Likewise, an employee who needs to adjust certain behaviours should not have to wait nine months to find out.

Feedback is generally more useful when it is given close to the action. When a manager promptly acknowledges a job well done, that recognition has greater impact. When they intervene quickly to address a gap, the opportunities for improvement are generally greater. The longer the delay, the more likely the message is to lose its value.

The manager’s role has changed

Our HR Consulting Services Team also believes that expectations of managers have evolved considerably. In the past, many managers were primarily responsible for operations. Today, they are also expected to develop their teams, engage employees, plan for succession, and support talent development.

To fulfil this role effectively, one annual meeting is generally not enough.

Employees want to understand where they are headed. They want to know what they do well, what they could improve, and what development opportunities are available to them. They also want the chance to ask questions and discuss their own aspirations. These conversations are more valuable when they happen frequently and naturally rather than only as part of an annual form.

Should we eliminate annual performance reviews?

Our HR Consulting Services Team does not think so. In our view, annual reviews remain relevant when they are used as a structured opportunity for reflection. They allow us to step back, assess the year’s objectives, discuss professional development, and plan what comes next. However, they should never be the only conversation about performance.

When an organization relies exclusively on annual reviews to manage employee performance, it often misses many opportunities for adjustment, recognition, and development. Conversely, when it builds a culture of continuous feedback, the annual review becomes much richer and more useful.

Rethinking performance management

At Bédard Ressources, our HR Consulting Services Team regularly helps organizations improve their performance management practices, including by developing tailored tools, coaching managers, and strengthening team engagement. Our experience shows, however, that beyond tools and processes, it is the quality and frequency of conversations between managers and employees that make all the difference. The best performance conversations do not necessarily happen during the annual review, but throughout the year.

Ultimately, performance cannot be reduced to a form or a meeting scheduled on the calendar. It is built day by day through conversations, follow-ups, encouragement, and adjustments made throughout the year.

And perhaps the real question is no longer how to improve our annual reviews, but rather how to have better conversations with our employees throughout the year.

To learn more about our HR Consulting Services and how our team can support your organization with performance management, contact Stéphane Pépin at spepin@bedardressources.com.

Share article

Other related articles

Everyone wants better employees. But what about employers?

October 30, 2026Human Resources Services
When an organization struggles with recruitment or employee retention, the response is often fairly predictable. We talk about labour shortages, analyze the job market, look at what…
better-employees

Your best employee may not be who you think

October 21, 2026Human Resources Services
When you ask a manager who their best employees are, the answer usually comes fairly quickly. They think of the person who delivers the best results. The one who works hard. The one who…
best-employee

A good manager doesn’t have all the answers

October 14, 2026Human Resources Services
When we talk about leadership, many people still picture a manager as someone who has all the answers. Someone who knows the operations better than anyone else, solves problems quickly,…
good-manager

Employees don’t need a perfect manager, but a predictable one

October 1, 2026Human Resources Services
When we talk about leadership, we often focus on the qualities a good manager should have. They should know how to motivate, communicate, listen, make decisions, delegate, recognize good…
predictible-manager